How a Torsen (geared) differential biases torque, where it stops working, and how it compares with an adjustable plated limited slip differential in motorsport use.
A Torsen differential and a plated limited slip differential (LSD) have the same purpose: to keep as much torque as possible going to the driven wheels, while still letting the wheels turn at different speeds in a corner. Both use friction to do so, but they create and use that friction in very different ways. This article explains how a Torsen differential works and how it compares with a plated LSD, such as the Drexler units that KMP Drivetrain Products supplies. It assumes that the reader knows how an open differential and a plated LSD work; the second is covered in Plated limited slip differential explained.
A Torsen differential, also called a geared or helical differential, has no spider gears and side gears like an open differential or a plated LSD. In the design described here it has worm gears on the two output shafts and worm wheels that are carried in the differential casing. Spur gears on the ends of the worm wheels connect the worm wheels to each other.
The main components of a Torsen differential.When the car drives straight, the worm wheels simply push against the worm gears and turn both wheels at the same speed. Because both wheels travel at the same speed, the worm wheels do not need to turn around their own axis.
As long as the torque at both wheels is equal, a Torsen behaves like an open differential. If one output shaft turns faster, it turns its worm gear. Through the worm wheels and the spur gears, the worm gear of the other shaft is turned in the opposite direction relative to the casing. That makes a speed difference between the wheels possible in a corner: the inner wheel turns slower by exactly the amount the outer wheel turns faster.
If one wheel starts to spin, the Torsen biases torque to the wheel with grip. It does this through friction inside the differential: between the worm gears and the worm wheels, between the worm gears themselves, and between the worm wheels and the housing in which they turn. This friction is there by design, and it is what makes the unit a limited slip differential. Under load the gears cannot rotate freely, and the friction between them restricts the speed difference between the two wheels.
How far a Torsen can bias the torque is given by its torque bias ratio. The ratio depends on the design of the gears and the friction points; 4:1 is used here as an example. With a 4:1 ratio, the wheel with more grip can receive four times the torque of the other wheel, a split of 80% to 20%.
Note that this is four times the torque that the other wheel can transfer to the road. It does not mean that the full engine torque can always be used. An example, with all values taken as torque at the differential:
Compared with a plated LSD, a helical LSD is quiet and needs little maintenance. That makes it a common choice for road cars: it is installed and needs no further attention. In a race car, where the driveline is loaded far more heavily and is maintained regularly anyway, noise and maintenance carry less weight.
The locking characteristic of a Torsen is very linear from zero lock to the maximum lock it can reach. There is no stick-slip point as with a plated LSD, which makes a Torsen easy and predictable to drive.
A car with a Torsen will not move with one driven wheel in the air. A wheel that is in the air, or has no traction at all, takes very little torque to turn. The gears need torque to generate the thrust forces that maintain the bias ratio. Without torque the gears are not pressed together, no friction is generated and the gears rotate freely. The unloaded wheel spins up but transfers little or no torque. The Torsen still sends torque to the wheel with traction according to the bias ratio, but four times zero is zero: the wheel with grip receives no torque and the unit acts as an open differential.
Over a kerb the inside wheel can be unloaded completely.A plated LSD does have torque available for the wheel with traction in this situation, limited by the preload in its clutch pack.
The torque bias ratio of a Torsen is determined by its design. A different ratio requires different helix angles on the gears or different friction characteristics of the main components. It cannot be adjusted on an existing unit.
Forces and torques within the Torsen differential. Source: Chocholek SE (1988), The development of a differential for the improvement of traction control. C368/88 © IMechE.A plated LSD can be matched to the car, the driver and the circuit. The pressure angles, the preload, the type of friction plates and the number of plates can all be changed, and each has a clear effect. The same differential can therefore be set up for different circuits and surfaces.
| Torsen LSD | Plated LSD | |
|---|---|---|
| Maintenance | Low | Periodic maintenance needed |
| Adjustability | Very limited | Adjustable to car, driver and circuit |
| Noise | Low | Noisier than an open differential |
| One wheel unloaded | No drive | Limited drive through the preload |
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
Both types have their strengths. For motorsport use, KMP regards the adjustability of the plated LSD as its main advantage. Which type suits a car depends on what the car has to do and on the kind of driving or racing it is built for.
The plated limited slip differentials, complete differential units and rebuild parts that KMP supplies are listed under Differentials. For advice on a differential for a specific car, contact KMP.